Patricia Heaton Articles >> 2006
July 20 2006

Heaton pilot didn't take off for fall lineup

By Mark Dawidziak | Cleveland Plain Dealer

You may have heard that Bay Village native Patricia Heaton was supposed to have a comedy on ABC this fall. Her production company did film a pilot episode for this series, but the network's entertainment president, Stephen McPherson, said the show wasn't strong enough to make the fall schedule.

"We really felt that it never got to the level that we needed," McPherson said when asked about Heaton's project. "You know, she can really make the phone book funny, so that was a missed opportunity for us. But right now, we're talking to the producers about whether there's a redevelopment on it. But, as a show, it really did not come together as we had hoped."

Heaton is best known for playing Debra Barone on the CBS hit "Everybody Loves Raymond," which began its prime-time run in September 1996. The role netted her two consecutive Emmy awards for outstanding lead actress in a comedy.

With "Raymond" having filmed its last episode, it was announced in February 2005 that Heaton had signed a seven-figure development deal with Disney-owned ABC and its sister studio, Touchstone TV. The deal was for both series and long-form projects from Four Boys Films, the production company run by Heaton and her husband, actor-writer-director David Hunt.

Four Boys, founded in 2001 and named for the couple's four sons, produced "The Engagement Ring," a cable movie that aired on TNT.

"Patricia is a true television star, and we're thrilled to be in business with her," McPherson said when the deal was announced. "While we look forward to finding the right project for her considerable acting skills, we are equally as excited to see what comes out of the development part of the deal."

He got to see both in the unnamed comedy delivered to ABC earlier this year. Heaton starred as Janet Daily, a widow balancing the demands of starting a physical-therapy practice and being a mom to two boys. Janet finds two unlikely friends when she joins the PTA. The first, a former Vegas showgirl played by Jenny McCarthy, is a free spirit trying to bond with her stepdaughter. The other is Rachel (Sherri Shepard), the offbeat school principal being driven crazy by type-A parents.

The premise was to explore what suburban moms must handle during the 9-to-3 weekday hours when the kids are in school. Also in the cast were Justine Bateman, Mo Collins, Lance Barber, Philip Anthony-Rodriguez and Rebecca Wisocky.

Although ABC currently is known as the home of such hourlong hits as "Lost," "Grey's Anatomy" and "Desperate Housewives," McPherson did order four half-hour comedies for the fall lineup. They are: "Big Day," which follows Alice (Marla Sokoloff) and Danny (Josh Cooke) through the highs and lows of their wedding day; "Help Me Help You," starring Ted Danson as a self-obsessed self-help guru; "The Knights of Prosperity" (Donal Logue and first announced as "Let's Rob..."), about a janitor's plan to rob Mick Jagger; and "Notes From the Underbelly," about a couple having a baby and trying to keep it a secret.

Each of these comedies, however, is a so-called one-camera show, which means it's filmed on location, like a movie or drama series. Think "Scrubs," "The Office" and "My Name Is Earl."

Not one is a traditional multicamera situation comedy filmed on a soundstage before a live audience. Think "Two and a Half Men," "Everybody Loves Raymond" and classic living-room comedies going all the way back to "I Love Lucy."

"We didn't say, 'We don't want any comedies without laugh tracks, we don't want any multicamera [shows],' " McPherson said during ABC's portion of the television critics' semiannual press tour. "We certainly went out there and said we want to break the mold. We feel like the same-old same-old is not working.

"So the traditional three-camera, couch-in-the-middle sitcom didn't seem to be breaking out at all. There weren't great voices. There weren't the Roseanne and the Tim Allen voices behind those kind of shows. I still feel they can absolutely work. And we did a bunch of multicamera pilots, but they didn't turn out the way we like. We feel these are the strongest comedies we have."

Reached by telephone, Heaton declined to comment on where things stand, but McPherson did say the show might be overhauled and repurposed as a midseason replacement.